Occasionally, we end up with extra cookies after a drop. Some may be a little wonky, but they’re all baked the same and taste just as good. When Mystery Boxes are available, we announce them via text on Sunday afternoons, so make sure you’re subscribed!

What you’ll receive:
One mystery box of extra-large cookies. Flavor combinations vary and are a total surprise. You might get four of one flavor, two of another, six different cookies, or something in between.

Because these boxes are mixed and unpredictable, cookies may contain egg, dairy, peanuts, soy, and/or other common allergens.

Cookies are baked fresh and ship once per week. They’re best enjoyed within a few days of arrival, or frozen in the bag for up to 3 months. Warm before eating for a peak cookie-eating experience.

Made by the Good Fuckin’ Cookies team using Beth’s original recipes, lots of love, and just a hint of spite.