The Cookie Vault

Welcome to the Cookie Vault, where we celebrate past seasonal flavors that have graced our lineup! 

Filter by

    • $
      $

Sort by

Reviews from the Cookie Gang

Frequently Asked Questions

Will these flavors ever return?

Occasionally, we bring back fan favorites for special events or surprise drops! Stay tuned on social media for updates.

Are these cookies still available for purchase?

Yes! You can still special order retired flavors by filling out this form.

How can I vote for a flavor to come back?

Let us know via social media or email! We love hearing which flavors you want to see again.