The Cookie Vault

Welcome to the Cookie Vault, where we celebrate past seasonal flavors that have graced our lineup! 

Filter by

    • $
      $

Sort by

Reviews from the Cookie Gang

Mexican Chocolate

Brian M.

Evil cookies

Impossible to resist. They stripped most of my self control and they were all gone way too soon. Excellent chocolate flavor, just a hint of heat, and excellent balance of flavors.

Product: Mexican Chocolate
Molasses Madness

Heather B.

Best Molasses Cookie EVER

The best molasses cookie I have ever eaten. Packaged perfectly and arrived safely with no broken cookies.

Product: Molasses Madness

Frequently Asked Questions

Will these flavors ever return?

Occasionally, we bring back fan favorites for special events or surprise drops! Stay tuned on social media for updates.

Are these cookies still available for purchase?

Yes! You can still special order retired flavors by filling out this form.

How can I vote for a flavor to come back?

Let us know via social media or email! We love hearing which flavors you want to see again.

We use cookies to improve your experience on our website. By browsing this website, you agree to our use of cookies. For more information see our privacy policy.